Monday, March 16, 2009

How Conservative Are You?

The Orator blog has a link to a fascinating questionnaire which seeks to identify how "conservative" one is. You have to answer 40 questions and then it gives you a rating on a scale of 1 to 400. The lower the score, the more conservative you are. The average American scores 209.

My score was 187. Take the questionnaire HERE. I'll start a league table if some well known bloggers take part. Donal Blaney scored 68!!! But as Barry Goldwater might say: "Extremism in the defense of liberty is no vice and that moderation in the pursuit of justice is no virtue".

124 comments:

Donal Blaney said...

I am pleased to see I am even more libertarian now than I had realised!

The Filthy Engineer said...

I've lurched to the right with 146.

Boo said...

Good grief I'm more conservative than america (173).
Still a lot of the the question could have been answered yes, but...

Unknown said...

316/400 - Should I even be reading this blog with a score like that? :S

Daily Referendum said...

I scored 175.

davidc said...

oh the disgrace of finding out i am a 'progressive'!

still, i can always plead the headaches

TheBoilingFrog said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Old Holborn said...

Old Holborn scores 193

Pete Wass said...

83. Bugger. I was so chuffed when the last one of these had me more right wing than Donal.

Conand said...

I was exactly neutral with 200/400. Everything in moderation and all that.
I'm usually just left of centre on the co-ordinate polls. Blaney's podcasts are very gradually re-wiring me.
The man Blaney is some sort of Anarcho-Capitalist.
Dale was paid to get that score by The Conservative Party (& I was paid by Polly to say that.)

Oldrightie said...

Minus 10 for oldrightie!

Alix said...

264. Though the questions aren't great for detecting liberals - I'll have answered a lot of the small state type questions the same way as conservatives.

Dazzler78 said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Anoneumouse said...

129/400

Dazzler78 said...

160! Still a conservative but not as extreme as Donal!!

Anonymous said...

215 here (I gave some pretty Conservative answers!). 68 is pathetic!

Harry Cole said...

Tory Bear got 137

TB

Johnny Norfolk said...

I came out at 215. No suprise there then.

Cath said...

211

Iain Dale said...

Johnny Norfolk, so I am more Conservative than you. Remember that!

Anonymous said...

165 here. I suspect that is rather low for an academic...

Desperate Dan said...

I am a Progressive 217.

Jason Brown said...

Jason Brown - Whipped Senseless blog, I got 210.

Anonymous said...

I scored 138 hmm...

Roger Evans said...

I got 142 - nice to see colleagues' opinions of me confirmed.

And good to see you on Saturday evening iain.

Paul Halsall said...

339.

Neil said...

I scored 134, which I think is unacceptably high. I wonder why that quiz made me such a lefty. Maybe it is something to do with the fact it is primarily aimed at Americans. In general, I would have guessed my score should be well under 100.

I probably dont qualify as a well known blogger, so perhaps that will allow me to avoid the shame of being at the "liberal" (read lefty) end of your league table.

Neil said...

Having read the posts I see that 134 would put me at the good end of any table, but still not top of the league.

Anonymous said...

219.

Plato said...

222/400 - guess I need to read my blog more :)

Unknown said...

350 - guess I'm far too progressive to read this blog. I'm going to give myself a right liberal talking to.

Richard Abbot said...

215 - must be something wrong there because i say Sarah Palin for President!?

Victor, NW Kent said...

191 - with 5 more liberal points I would have become a Baptist!

strapworld said...

101 !!!!

I am 'very conservative'!!

Simon Gardner said...

And Tory head bangers note:

STOP PRESS STOP PRESS

Cameron at today’s presser reiterated (whilst saying no license fee rise) full Conservative party support for the BBC and its centrality to our life and the British way of life.

“I am a supporter of the BBC. I am a supporter of the license fee. I think the license fee can go on.”

I don’t think there’s much room there for the more idiotic rantings here (especially recently) about how the BBC will be broken up/abolished/castrated under any putative Cameron government.

For which I say - “phew”. As well as - “I told you so”.

Events dear boy, events said...

I scored 246 which surprised me.

Anonymous said...

I scored 85/400, I was only a little surprised.

Weygand said...

250 - I think I've just discovered that I am really a Lib Dem - the shame of it.

Paul Burgin said...

I scored 256 out of 400

Lola said...

127 - humph.

yarnesfromhorsham said...

201 and yes Im over 64

RobW said...

Scored 159. Problem with the test is it mixes moral conservativeness with liberal economics. So I don't think I could have scored any less.

Also the idea that the Democrats are Liberals is laughable -- socialists would be a far better term.

Mark Fulford said...

277 for me.

Donal's 68 is slightly scary. How do you get such a low score?

JoeF said...

161- so conservative rupublican in US- probably about right

It has been mentioned above but quite a few questions are very US- centric and hence based on their views, especially socially- where "conservative" in US is Government should ban XYZ, rather than libertarian.

janestheone said...

214 - no surprise, would have been more, but I am a neocon on foreign policy

BSH said...

240 - A traditional American Democrat. Doesn't surprise me much, I'm right wing in Scottish politics and right of centre in british; thus left in American.

Eckersalld said...

210...

Marks me down as a Progressive, although I'm normally marked as a Libertarian in these things!

Rt. Hon. E.B. said...

129/400 - on top Conservative form :D

Anonymous said...

I scored 192.

Shane Frith said...

133 - As a libertarian, I'm worried about being described as very conservative!

Donal Blaney said...

@ Mark Fulford: it's because, as a libertarian, I voted no whenever a question sought agreement with government spending or government expansion.

Richard Lowe said...

233 for me. Less than I'd anticipated to be honest.

James Manning said...

201! Thought i'd be more around the 160-mark, but am becoming more progressive as i get older.

All Seeing Eye said...

Hmmm. TheEye got 50. Is this something to be nervous about?

Nicked for my blog, methinks.

Anonymous said...

309. Which I'm quite pleased about. Don't undetstand how anyone could get less than 100!!

Anonymous said...

I scored 320. Progressive! That's as good as being called Old European!

MikeyP said...

156 for me! Maybe we need another of these aimed specifically at the UK

M said...

207

Kerron said...

289 out of 400 - very progressive.

I'm not surprised about that, I normally come out alongside Mahatma Gandhi on these sort of things!

DiscoveredJoys said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
DiscoveredJoys said...

I'm Progressive (250) by American standards, but by UK standards I'm exactly central on the left/right axis and slightly libertarian - which means I am out of step with all 3 main UK parties.

No wonder I feel disaffected. Mind you, I suspect there will be an outbreak of 'small statism' real soon now...

All Seeing Eye said...

Can't understand less than 100 Bucket of Tongues?

Just by answering the questions realistically IMHO.

I'm guessing that you wouldn't want to live in my country and I wouldn't want to live in yours though.

The Young Oligarch said...

127 and proud !

Neil said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Nick Thornsby said...

307

Sixxstring90 said...

108

nostalgic said...

Woot!! 152=)

Sam Ellis said...

309/400

niconoclast said...

I am 30/400 but because I came third in my class for math but there were only 3 in the class I am struggling to tell what my score means.(Help.)

justoneglass said...

193 - just like OH

jon dee said...

230- I blame the BBC.

Filter said...

203. I'm in the Centre. Does that make me a fence sitter? Would be interested in a UK version of this test!

Baldwin said...

I scored 211 which counts as progressive (just).

Perhaps this makes me a Cameroon.

Owen Polley said...

221. Which makes me progressive apparently. It just goes to show that left - right is far too simplistic in terms of defining politics. I suppose it's just about fun though.

PETER MARTINOVIC said...

64/400

Steve Yeardley said...

365....wrong place for me it seems.

Mirtha Tidville said...

196....says I`m Conservative.......Thank God for that then.

Lord Elvis of Paisley said...

172 for me.

Daily Referendum said...

Obama voters 244 - Sh*t that's scary.

Unknown said...

156 for me. About where I would have expected.

alistair said...

97 but as a libertarian some of the questions made me very uncomfortable

OBC News said...

187 here - snap!

Jimmy said...

316


I'll get me coat.

Colin said...

152

Adrian said...

250 (progressive)

There were 3 or 4 poorly worded questions.

Hey said...

70 - it was the "policies are geared toward the rich and corporations" question that hung me up. They're really writing from a Leftist perspective and not understanding that some of us most fervent rightwingers dislike the state because of how it inherently serves entrenched interests. Regulations aren't much of an issue for large firms but strangle innovation, while taxes screw people who are working and building businesses but are fairly easy to avoid by those who are already rich (see the Kennedys, Warren Buffet, Theresa Heinz Kerry, George Soros).

Lots of the social issues were horribly badly worded, for someone who disagrees with Leftists as well as social conservatives. It's fairly obvious that life begins at conception (arguments to the contrary are crap and represent the inherent weakness and cowardly nature of those proposing them), but I view abortion in the first trimester to be legitimate given viability, spontaneous miscarriage, and the requirements of women's liberty. Plus I'm a big fan of hypocrisy in terms of sexuality - adults should be able to do what they want, with whom, as long as it's behind closed doors and doesn't affect children. Too much of the current social liberal view thinks there should be no standards of public behaviour, instead of just no laws against behaviour...

Anonymous said...

I got 117! My IQ is 20 points higher!

Lets get the commies! Nuke them! I can be Donal's deputy!

subrosa said...

250. Liberal it says but I prefer the tag progressive. Interesting though thanks Iain.

Anonymous said...

I scored 183. I'm thick. Is that good or bad? I still don't understand the whole right or left thing.
Mummy x

Charlotte Gore said...

179. Insanity.

Anonymous said...

Iain

I scored 212!!

Null said...

Oh dear, I scored 260...

Daniel1979 said...

169/400. I thought I would have scored a lower number.

@molesworth_1 said...

263 - but I had a great walk today, so I must be feeling benevolent. If I'd done it at the end of a different day, it might have been quite different.

Archbishop Cranmer said...

202

His Grace is throwing himself back on the faggots.

nought.point.zero said...

207 - slightly progressive

Probably because I'm keen on gays and minorities and such

Unknown said...

same as you Iain - 187.

I was banking on 'Should we nuke Iran?' and 'Should we spey the underclass?' to get my score down a bit, but they didn't appear

Unknown said...

Hey March 16, 2009 5:44 PM
but I view abortion in the first trimester to be legitimate given viability, spontaneous miscarriage, and the requirements of women's liberty.
----------------------------------

Yeah that poor first-semester foetus about to be injected in the heart, decapitated, or whatever the execution method of choice is, might have a view on what is and isn't 'legitimate'.

You can be pro-abortion if you want, but don't try and 'legitimise' it with cod-intellectualising.

Murder is what it is.

Nothing more, nothing less.

Unsworth said...

@ Cranmer

"His Grace is throwing himself back on the faggots"

Would you care to reconsider the phrasing?

Unsworth said...

Anyway, this is an American definition of 'Conservative'. Nowhere near what the UK definition might be.

Bishop Brennan said...

I'm ultra-'conservative', with 142 - sounds about right... But I'm not entirely sure that this is the right scale any more - e.g. I disagreed with the 'conservative' opinion on gay rights...

John Moorcraft said...

Those who know me will not be surprised when I suggest my score was a somewhat progressive 262.

I tried to be as sound as I possibly could as well. Time to book myself on the next YBF Conf methinks.

Simon Gardner said...

iain said... “Yeah that poor...”

Aah. Hence the repellant Nadine Dorries thing. I had wondered.

Incidentally, I don’t know what you’ve done to your blog but it’s suddenly started consistently crashing Safari this evening and I’ve had to move over to Firefox temporarily For Iain Dale purposes (which is a pain). Presumably Camino would still be OK.

Any idea what’s going on?

[Your US quiz actually crashed my router!]

Unknown said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Simon Gardner said...

Tried the quiz again and it froze at Q.39 - sex 'n' violence. At least it didn’t crash the router this time.

Peter the Lawyer said...

The one thing that I think many people don't seem to understand is that a true Conservative may have views about cultural issues, but at the same time does not wish the State to enforce those views. Hence, I think that a lot of the gay subculture is awful, but I certainly wouldn't want the State to act in any way to supress that subculture or interfere with it in any way. Neither would I want the Government to support that culture in any way nor prevent me from expressing my opinion on the matter. Simirlarly, I think single parenthood should be avoided, but I don'r want the Government to campaign against it or ban it. Though, I certainly don't think the Government should subsidise it by paying benefits to teenage mothers.

Peter the Lawyer said...

The one thing that I think many people don't seem to understand is that a true Conservative may have views about cultural issues, but at the same time does not wish the State to enforce those views. Hence, I think that a lot of the gay subculture is awful, but I certainly wouldn't want the State to act in any way to supress that subculture or interfere with it in any way. Neither would I want the Government to support that culture in any way nor prevent me from expressing my opinion on the matter. Simirlarly, I think single parenthood should be avoided, but I don'r want the Government to campaign against it or ban it. Though, I certainly don't think the Government should subsidise it by paying benefits to teenage mothers.

CityUnslicker said...

I got 176

Steve H said...

253.

What I don't understand is this statement:

"Free market solutions are better than goverment at producing economic opportunity."

The lower a score you give that, the less you agree with it and so the more conservative you are. So conservatives believe that government runs the economy better than the market.

Eh? Isn't that statement arse about face?

Ian Simcox said...

207. I'm an average American, oh joy.

Anonymous said...

G.O.T. score of 214

Opinicus said...

177 Conservative

Got to agree with the comments above. This is a quiz by American leftists that lacks any understanding of a Conservative position that isn't Mary Whitehouse.

Lucy said...

172.Conservative Kiwi

Rush-is-Right said...

I got 69.

Tory Teacake said...

184
Phew - just plain 'conservative'

Unknown said...

taken the quiz and scored 89 making me 'extremely Conservative'.
Very proud of that score indeed.

rose22 said...

271/400, and I didn't think I was that progressive!

Unknown said...

247/400

It just goes to ahow you can't be too careful.

Oscar Miller said...

A perfect 150. But how on earth did a bunch of socialist imbeciles manage to get themselves called 'progressive'. They should be called 'retrograde'. And the word 'conservative' is increasingly being used in a perjorative context. For instance the BBC love to call Ahmadinjead's crew 'conservative' - especially after they've just hung a gay person. The bleedin' left are hijacking the language along with everything else.

Anonymous said...

I find myself in good company, Mr. Dale: I scored 196! I'm relieved. I can't imagine scoring 68, but honestly--anything over 215 would have had me severely panicked.

Uncork that Martinelli's, now.

Oliver Rowlinson said...

I got 107. WOW!!

Anonymous said...

307

Anonymous said...

Unbelievable, canvas. Congrats on not following your result with a series of frustrated expletives.

Cicero said...

234, but I agree the questions are not so relvent to the Uk and the phrasing is sometimes ambiguous