Monday, July 16, 2007

Brown's Chickens Come Home to Roost

Today is an important day. It is a day some of Gordon Brown's chickens will come home to roost. My friend Christian Wolmar tells me that Metronet are going to be knocking on Mayor Livingstone's door this morning and saying "sorry, but we can't run these undergound contracts and we will have to go into administration"

The maintenance and refurbishment of two thirds of the tube lines (9 out of 12) now lie in tatters. No doubt the poor bloody taxpayer will be called on again, but this is a huge embarrassment for Gordon Brown as the whole scheme was his idea in the first place. He was warned by experts at the time that these were unworkable and too complex (they cost £500 million to draw up) but he went ahead anyway.

It is now time for the National Audit Office to launch a full scale inquiry into these contracts and how Metronet has failed to control costs. Witness number one should be the First Lord of the Treasury.

Rocket Attacks on Israel Justified Says Palestinian Ambassador



Tonight at 8pm 18 Doughty Street is broadcasting a 60 minute interview with the Palestinian Ambassador in London, Manuel Hassassian. Click above to watch a three minute taster. During the interview, he asserts...

* that rocket attacks on Israel from Gaza, the West Bank or Lebanon are justified - even if innocent civilians are killed;
* that the famous footage of Palestinians dancing for joy on the streets on 9/11 was faked by the Israelis;
* that Hamas should apologise to the Palestinian people; and says that while the Taleban may have been a little excessive in their modus operandi, at least they kept order.

You can watch the full programme HERE.

Steve Norris Should Stand Against Boris But the Others Should Depart the Scene

Over the weekend I have lost count of the number of people who asked me whether I thought Boris would stand. My reply each time was that I hadn't got a clue. Well now we know. Between now and noon, the other candidates have to decide whether there is any point in putting themselves forward. My advice to them - with one exception - would be that they shouldn't bother.

Over the last few months I have interviewed most of the other potential candidates on 18 Doughty Street. I've been impressed by their commitment and enthusiasm, but none of them stand a chance against Boris, with one exception. The exception is Steve Norris.

The reason I hope Steve still decides to stand is that Boris needs to be tested and Steve is just the man to provide the test. In addition, Steve could actually beat Boris to the nomination or be there to pick up the pieces if for whatever reasons Boris's candidacy self combusts.

Nozzer v Bozzer. It would be a fascinating contest and bring the Conservative Party in London to life.

UPDATE: Boris to launch his campaign at 2pm.

UPDATE: Tory Radio is conducting a phone in - where people can leave a message on 0845 257 0 427 leaving a message, "I'm backing Boris because....." Go on, you know you want to...

UPDATE: Boris's campaign website is HERE.

UPDATE: Rumour is that Steve Norris is NOT running...

UPDATE: Guido explains HERE why Boris will win

Sunday, July 15, 2007

60% As Influential as The Grauniad - I Have Never Been So Insulted

I am not sure I understand THIS but according to the Onalytica blog (no jokes please) my blog is 15% as influential as the BBC and 60% as influential as The Guardian when it discusses David Cameron. I think. It's some sort of benchmarking thing. But I'm not a management consultant, so I don't pretend I really understand it.

Tony Lit & THAT Donation

Thanks to all those who have wished me a happy birthday either here or on Facebook. I have spent it at my parents near Saffron Walden, where there is no internet access, hence the lack of blogging today.

I have, however, been amused to read all the comments about my lack of posting on Sunrise Radio's £4800 donation to Labour. For the record, on last night's paper review on News 24 I not only chose that as one of my topics to talk about, I also talked about the two bad polls for the Conservatives. I also praised two LibDem MPs (see below). So please don't let anyone accuse me of trying to hide away from subjects which are difficult for the Tories.

On the Tony Lit front, I doubt whether the donation has lost him a single vote. Indeed, the blanket media coverage has raised his profile enormously - his picture is everywhere in today's papers. You could easily argue that the coverage is a boost. Personally, I cannot imagine why any Conservative would want to attend a Labour Party event, but we should remember it was an Asian business 'do', and a media organisation like Sunrise presumably has good reason to be impartial in its political relations.

I did find it interesting to note, though, that tables cost £4,800 - just £200 below the declaration limit. Another case of Labour operating at the margins.

UPDATE: Sense from Dizzy.

You Can't Have Your Children Back

Last night on News 24 I went out of my way to pay tribute to two LibDem MPs, John Hemming and Norman Lamb, who have been campaigning against forced adoption. Their interest in the subject came as a result of social services taking children from their constituents, then allowing them to be adopted by new parents before charges of child abuse against their constituents had been found dropped or found to be false. At that point the parents were told they would not be getting their children back. You can read more in the Mail on Sunday (pp57-59) or Sunday Telegraph (p8). It's a terrible and moving story and provides a warning against the all powerful State machine.

Saturday, July 14, 2007

News 24 at 11.45pm

Tonight I'll be reviewing the Sunday papers on BBC News 24 alongside freelance journalist Kate Bevan. Join us at 11.45pm.

And then at midnight I shall be mourning celebrating my 45th birthday. Cue 47,000 blog readers in a chorus of Happy Birthday ... or not...

Two Bad Polls for the Conservatives

Two polls are out tonight which are not good news for the Conservatives. At all. Both are by ICM and both show a seven point Labour lead. The News of the World poll shows a vote split of 35-28-13, while the Sunday Telegraph figures are 40-33-19. The ICM NOTW poll also showed that 53% of people felt Gordon Brown was best equipped to lead Britain, compared to 27% for David Cameron. Earlier this year, ICM gave the Tory leader a five-point lead over Mr Brown on their personal ratings.

However, the Sunday Telegraph poll gave some encouragement to Cameron, with strong support for his stance on the importance of marriage. Some 70% of voters felt it was better for parents to be married. Forty nine per cent backed plans for giving tax incentives for marriage, with 44% against.

Footnote: Isn't it bizarre that two polls from the same polling organisation (oth with 1,0003 respondents) give different figures? Perhaps someone at PoliticalBetting.com could explain.

UPDATE: Ian Kirby from the NOTW explains that it was a shared poll with the Sun Tel. He says: "In response to your query about different results, Paddy did a state of the parties question. We asked "which party do you feel warmest too?" (to gauge potential floating voters) and crossed it with how did you vote in the last election".

Tories to Sue LibDems Over Ealing Leaflet

Oh dear. The Ealing Southall by-election campaign looks set to get even more tribal on Monday, as the LibDems face legal action over the unauthorised use of a picture of Tory candidate Tony Lit on their latest leaflet. I have to say it is a bit odd for them to be using a picture of him. Normally they shy away from even mentioning an opposition candidate, let alone using a picture of him. Anyway, they have upset Tory campaign managers greatly. A spokesman told me...


For years we've turned the other cheek as the LibDems have wilfully broken
copyright in order to gain political advantage by misrepresenting our material.
Now the time has come to say enough is enough. Yesterday we provided formal
notice that we required the copyright infringement to cease, but were
disappointed to note that despite an acknowledgement of our request, they
actually continued to distribute their copyright infringed material. We have
therefore had no alternative but to ask solicitors to draft proceedings which
will be presented when the Court opens on Monday morning. Under the
circumstances we will be seeking an injunction and damages. It's quite wrong
that the LibDems don't seem to feel that they should be bound by the same
copyright laws as everyone else.


Costs are expected to run to around £10,000 according to the Tories. In the meantime, the Tories are distributing this leaflet, which those in the know, looks very much like a LibDem one. Great stuff!



I have to say as a Tory that it is nice to see the LibDems get a taste of their own medicine. Whatever the result of this by-election Grant Shapps and his team have drawn a line in the sand and taken on the LibDems in a way which has rarely happened in the past.

The First 80 Pages of Alastair Campbell

Having read the first 80 pages of Alastair Campbell's diaries I have two reactions. The first is that it's a brilliant read and I can't wait to read the rest of it on the plane to Rwanda on Thursday, but the second is that if it is an accurate reflection of the life of a newly opposition leader and his inner circle I a) feel very sorry for the people around David Cameron and b) feel very relieved DD didn't win!

I don't think anyone understand the pressures on political leaders and their advisers. Why should they? But it is clear that even after only a year in the job Campbell's relationship with his partner was at breaking point. She accused him of being obsessive and only concerned with 'TB'. The trouble is that if you're in a close knit political circle you do tend to have no life outside that circle. Those closest to you feel excluded and understandably react badly. Relationships which aren't strong do not always survive.

The picture Alastair Campbell paints of Tony Blair during his first year as leader is not a wholly positive one. He comes across as someone with an uncontrollable temper, prone to incoherant rants and not always clear on strategy. Campbell describes him as someone who treats his staff poretty badly, never says thank you to any of them and expects total devotion and loyalty. The thing is, he got it too. And that's part of what being a leader of people is about - commanding respect and loyalty even when you don't deserve it.

The two violent incidents which Campbell describes well involve Mandelson and Kinnock. Mandelson actually swung two punches at Campbell and Blair and to separate them - Mandelson goes up in my opinion. And then on a holiday in France Neil Kinnock launches into a violent tirade against Campbell accusing him and Blair of selling out, particualrly to Rupert Murdoch - "how do you think you'd fell if you had your head in a lightbulb?" - he rants. Campbell then thought he was about to get a kettle full of boiling water chucked at him. And this is the man who wanted to be Prime Minister.

As you can tell, I am thoroughly enjoying the book (which I can read in the happy knowledge that I didn't pay for it and therefore haven't contributed to the Alastair Campbell retirement fund)

Friday, July 13, 2007

Sky Tonight

I'm doing the paper review on Sky News tonight at 11.30pm. I wish I'd followed the Conrad Black trial a little more closely. Watch out for signs of blather, filling and bluster...

Labour Blogger Wants to be MP

Alex Hilton, who runs Recess Monkey and LabourHome has written an article on why he wants to be the next MP for Liverpool West Derby HERE. I shan't praise him at it would ruin any chances he has, but I have heard he may have some stiff opposition in the form of the former MP for Enfield, Stephen Twigg. Twiggy has as tenuous links with Liverpool as Alex, but he has been seen at various Party functions in the area pressing the flesh. It should be an interesting contest.

Cameroons to Launch ConHome Rival

Fraser Nelson reveals today that a new Conservative blog is being set up with the overt intention of providing a Cameron-supporting rival to the more off-message ConservativeHome. Called Platform 10, a beta version of the new blog will be appearing HERE soon.

Dizzy seems to think that Platform 10 has ConservativeHome in its sights and its aim is to destroy it. I doubt that. I am sure there is a frustration at CCHQ that they cannot control what is written on ConHome, but I doubt very much whether it will be any different with Platform 10. While the editorial stance will no doubt be very Cameron-friendly, if it just seen as a Steve Hilton mouthpiece they will find it hardgoing.

Contrary to what Fraser Nelson says I know for a fact that Platform 10 was not initiated by Steve Hilton. Steve is a good friend of Fiona Melville, the woman behind Platform 10. They worked together on David Cameron's leadership bid and are good friends, so naturally people put two and two together. But it was her idea and she's the brains behind it.

I think the advent of Platform 10 is a very good thing. Diversity usually is. I don't think ConHome should feel under threat, although it may be more difficult for them to get exclusives from certain members of the Shadow Cabinet. But, so what? It is such a huge site now, with a loyal following, and I suspect it will go from strength to strength. My prediction is that ConHome readers will indeed read Platform 10, just as my readers will too. The more sites the merrier.
In truth, the advent of Platform 10 is yet further proof that the right of centre blogosphere is flourishing and is in a very healthy state indeed. Contrast it with the poor efforts of the left. Is there a single left of centre blog that is a "daily must visit" site? There are several LibDem blogs that I visit most days, but very few Labour blogs. LabourHome is so on message that it's almost painful to read - a lesson which hopefully Platform 10 will have learned from.

The Friday Ad Treat



These are the four classic ads starring Joan Collins and the late, great Leonard Rossiter for Cinzano Bianco. Wonderful stuff.

How to Damn With Faint Praise: No 94

In an interview with the GMTV Sunday Programme Simon Hughes has this to say about his leader:

"Ming is well on the way to finding his best form again"

With friends like that...

Boris: Will He or Won't He?

Boris Johnson confirmed on his website this morning that he was standing for London mayor, and then ten minutes later the post disappeared, leaving his millions of fans in a state of distraughtness. This came hot on the heels of an Andrew Pierce story in the Telelgraph speculating that Boris would announce his bid today. The deadline for applications for mayoral candidates is on Monday.

My expectation is that Steve Norris will throw his hat into the ring again and probably announce it in one of the Sunday broadsheets. Nozzer and Bozzer stand head and shoulders above the dozen or so other candidates who have announced their intentions so far, certainly in terms of public profile. Mike Read is someone I wouldn't underestimate though.

Thursday, July 12, 2007

Never in the Field of...

Apparently they want to stop teaching Winston Churchill, according to tomorrow's Sun. My esteemed Norfolk friend Antony Little tells me "I can tell you one History teacher who will still teach Winston Churchill! They'd have to insert the chip before I stop teaching my favourite essay; "Churchill was the best PM ever. Agree in 500 words". Boom Boom

More Defections in Ealing...Gulp

HERE we go again...

LibDem Tax Proposals Make the Rich Pips Squeak

The primary role of any political party is to tell people what you will do in government and then how you will pay for it. About a year ago, the LibDems issued their tax proposals, which included a two pence cut in income tax. Although the proposals were revenue neutral they made quite a good attempt at selling the whole package as a tax cut. I wrote about the proposals HERE. I said...
Taxcutting is like supporting a football team. You have to believe in it within your soul. It's part of your political being. Unfortunately for most Liberal Democrats raising taxes is part of their political gene makeup and most voters know that. They remember the 1p on income tax "for education". They remember the spending commitments that would have bankrupted the country. They remember the
50p income tax rate. So although the LibDems will want to concentrate on the
headline of "2p off income tax" (are they suggesting 2p in the Pound off the
education budget?) it's the other measures which ought to be examined in minute
detail, as they will dramatically increase the tax burden on the middle classes
- just the sort of people the LibDems need to keep hold of (and attract) if they
are to repel the Cameroonian advances.

Today, the LibDems have announced yet another round of tax proposals, which include an apparently mouthwatering 4p cut in income tax (on top of their original 2p proposal, which was adopted by Gordon Brown in his March budget). But again, this is a revenue neutral package. They say that any household earning less than £68,000 will benefit. Let's take a closer look...

The main proposal is a 4p income tax cut to be paid for by "green taxes on cars and flights and the ending of £13.5bn of tax breaks for high earners would fund the cuts". As yet I have been unable to find any detail on what these tax breaks for high earners consist of. Sir Menzies Campbell said: "Tax cuts for the majority will be paid for by the wealthy minority." This is the politics of envy. As Lincoln said, you don't make the poor rich by making the rich poor. Many of the people Ming wants to tax until the pips squeak are the wealth generators of this country. They provide the jobs which pay for the benefits he wishes to increase. Let's look at some of the other measures...
Reaffirming the party's commitment to replacing the council tax with a "local income tax"
I'm unclear whether this move has been included in their calculation that any household earning less than £68,000 will be better off. This was a clear vote loser for the LibDems in the south of England last time and many LibDem activists are nervous about retaining it as a policy.
Removing "tax loopholes exploited by the super-rich"
Like what?
Reducing stamp duty paid on properties worth less than £500,000
And what about those over £500,000? It is licensed robbery for the Treasury to take a 4% cut.
Raising the starting threshold for inheritance tax to £500,000
A welcome start, but most LibDems I know would like IHT to be increased rather than cut
Return business rates to local control
This is a difficult one. In theory I agree with this and if you believe in localism you ought to be firmly in favour. And yet, and yet, I know the damage business rates can do to small businesses. Whatever its faults, the UBR has provided a degree of stability.
Simplify the tax code to remove more than 500 pages of regulations
All in favour of that
Bringing money made on UK property by people who are not resident in the UK, within capital gains tax
I'm not really qualified to comment on this, but my gut feeling is that it sets a dangerous precedent.

This is an interesting set of proposals, but on first sight at least, it doesn't provide the information needed to make a rational judgement. The full paper can be read HERE. Perhaps someone could point me to the section which details the £13.5 billion of tax breaks for the wealthy which will be abolished, because I am damned if I can find it.

Ming Wants Parliamentary Researchers as MPs

James Graham informs us on LibDem Voice that Ming Campbell held a reception this week for female LibDem parliamentary researchers. The aim was to persuade them all to get on the LibDem approved candidates list and stand for Parliament. The LibDems have an even worse problem than the Conservatives in getting women selected and then elected, so Ming's initiative should not be too surprising. However, instead of urging them to get on the candidates list in their early twenties, shouldn't he be encouraging them to go out and get some experience of the outside world before going into Parliament? Don't we have too many political apparatchiks in Parliament already? They can't all be as good as the excellent Jo Swinson.

Paddy Ashdown on Bosnia, Iraq & the LibDems



Earlier today I interviewed former LibDem leader Paddy Ashdown. The bulk of the 50 minute long interview concerned his career since he left Parliament, but in this ten minute long clip he talks about LibDem politics, the attempt by himself and Tony Blair to realign the left of British (he blames Gordon Brown for its failure) and the challenge now facing Ming Campbell. He says he believes Gordon Brown's attempts to build a government of all the talents were "genuine".

If you enjoy the clip, click HERE to watch the whole interview, in which we cover Bosnia, Iraq and his new book SWORDS AND PLOUGHSHARES.

Wednesday, July 11, 2007

BBC Bans Emily Maitlis Spectator Column

I've never seen Matthew D'Ancona fulminate before, but I suspect he might self combust when he appears on my 18 Doughty Street show tonight at 10pm. Why? Because the BBC have stopped Newsnight presenter Emily Maitlis from writing for The Spectator. Her diary last week provoked the ire of BBC head honcho Helen Boaden, who overrulled Head of News Peter Horrocks and told Maitliss she could in future keep her thoughts to herself. It seems the BBC are still in the post Hutton paranoia era. But it is still one rule for some and a different rule for others. Why is Andrew Marr's diary in the Telegraph more acceptable than an Emily Maitlis column in The Speccie? I am so very glad I don't have to watch what I say like everyone at the BBC seems to have to.

It does seem off that Boaden should intervene to overrule Horrocks. He will not have been pleased. Ever ready with a quotable phrase, D'Ancona has called it the Vicky Pollard School of Management - yes but, no but.

UPDATE: Update from Matt D'Ancona HERE. The BBC seems to have backed down. Sort of.

Brown Mops Up Last Week's Nuclear Mishap

At last week's PMQs Gordon Brown saiid the government would be going for nuclear power. That was a mistake because the High Court said there must be a full public consultation before a decision is taken (you'll remember Greenpeace's successful High Court Judicial Review). Brown had to find a way to withdraw the statement without getting political heat and being accused of being 'not ready for primetime'.

Here's a story about last week's mistake:
 

http://observer.guardian.co.uk/business/story/0,,2121044,00.html


 
Now, at today's PMQs a Labour MP asked a planted question about nuclear power and Brown looked down and read from a statement, saying he'd only decide after the consultation. It was a stealth withdrawl of his statement last week. The MP who asked him the question used to be the press officer for BNFL – Jamie Reed MP.
 
The point is, it was just like the old days. A planted question and a read-out statement to get the PM out of trouble. Glorious.

Place Your Bets on an Autumn Election?

I have to be honest at being a little mystified by Gordon Brown's statesment about the Queen's Speech. It was dressed up as being a grand gesture at allowing more scrutiny of planned government legislation, and for all I know it was genuinely that. But something has been gnawing away at me over the last hour and it's finally dawned on me what the true agenda might have been.

If you were a Prime Minister considering an autumn election, you'd want the country to know what you planned in your next session of parliament, but the election would probably take place before a planned Queen's Speech. So what do you do? You pull out the three or four juiciest bits to tantalise the electorate with and announce them a few months in advance, in an attempt to wrongfoot the opposition. You then call an election just before your opponents have finished their policy review and finalised their own policy positions. Sounds clever, doesn't it?

In fact it sounds far too clever to have any likelihood of being true at all. But just in case...

A Bore Draw at PMQs

This was a more confident, competent performance from Gordon Brown in his second outing as PMQs. I thought his joust with David Cameron was a score draw, although Brown did have a good line about Cameron focussing on PR, while he focussed on being PM. That was rather countered when he referred to Ming Campbell as the Leader of the Opposition. In his dreams!

It was interesting to note how many Tory MPs questioned the PM about the unfairness of the devolution settlement. The number of planted questions on the Labour benches was readily apparent. It was a sign that they were desperate to ensure that there would be no repeat of last week. To that extent the whips' operation was a success.

UPDATE: Dizzy congratulates the PM for being honest.

How the BBC Is Saying 'Sorry' to Alastair Campbell

I have just come back from doing an piece for 5 Live with Edwina Currie on Alastair Campbell's diaries. It was ostensibly to preview the 3 part BBC2 series which starts tonight. I had, in my naivety assumed that it was a three part documentary on Campbell and his reign of terror at Number Ten, but it seems I was wrong. The BBC, in its infinite wisdom, has paid a production company several hundred thousand of your licence fee payer pounds to make a three part puff for Campbell's diaries. Apparently, all it consists of is Campbell reading out extracts of his book. There are no interviews, no contextualisation, no analysis - nothing apart from Campbell reading out his book. Well excuse me while I go and watch paint dry, instead.

I can think of no one who book the BBC has publicised more than Alastair Campbell. I can think of no one who has ever had a full half an hour interview in the 8.10 slot of the Today Programme. I can think of no one who would be allowed three programmes simply to read their book out on prime time BBC2.

Is this the BBC's way of saying sorry?

Ironically, for Campbell it may all backfire. Campbell didn't do a newspaper serialisation, but the effect of all this publicity may be the same. If people think they have heard all about the book and know what's in it, they are unlikely to go out to a bookshop and spend £25 on buying it. Having said that, it is number 3 in the Amazon charts, so it can't be doing all that badly.

Experience tells me, however, that this book won't have legs. Some books sell large numbers in the first week of publication then barely sell a copy afterwards. Others have slower sales at the beginning of the sales cycle but will still be selling decent numbers six months later. I suspect Campbell's book falls into the first category.

Tuesday, July 10, 2007

How to Defect Twice in Twelve Hours

Earlier today I reported that a sixth Labour councillor in Ealing Southall had defected to the Conservatives. I had had this information under a 10am embargo since late last night, when I was sent a statement which Cllr Zahida Abbas Noori has agreed with her five colleagues who defected yesterday.

It seems that this morning she was persuaded not to defect after all, presumably by Tom Watson, Labour's beleagured by election campaign manager. He wrote THIS on his blog this afternoon.
The central office stooge is at it again. Iain Dale posted on his blog earlier today that a Southall Councillor Mrs Noori has defected to the Tories. There’s a small problem with this though. She hasn’t resigned. Councillor Noori is not happy about Iain Dale’s
slur. Lawyers are being consulted. Here’s the statement she has just asked to be issued on her behalf: “I joined the Labour Party to serve my community. That remains the case….. I have not resigned my membership and will not be joining the Conservatives. Tomorrow I will be leading campaigning for Labour’s victory on July 19th. I hope to see you on the campaign trail too!" Oh Iain. Councillor Noori is a member of the National Union of Journalists and knows her rights. Will we finally get an apology out of you?
Let's establish the facts, shall we?

1. Last night Cllr Noori did indeed agree with her five councillor colleagues that she would be joining them.
2. A statement was agreed with her, which I have, but I won't post unless she'd like me to.
3. The announcement was embargoed until 10am this morning.
4. Since I heard nothing to the contrary overnight I posted the story this morning.
5. Tom Watson then presumably persuaded Cllr Noori of the error of her ways.

Now, with regard to an apology, what is it exactly I'm to apologise for? Acting on information given to me in good faith and which was correct at the time of publication? It was even formatted on a Conservative Party press release, just like the one the previous day when the group of five defections was announced. I am sure that Cllr Noori, as a member of the NUJ, would accept that this was a pretty good reason to write the story.

Actually, on second thoughts, I will apologise. I am deeply sorry for Tom Watson that he has to put up with people like this when he's trying to run a by election campaign which is disintegrating before his eyes.

UPDATE: Here's a quote from a CCHQ spokesman: "Cllr Noori did agree twice on Monday night to leave the Labour Party to join the Conservatives in order to support Tony Lit's energetic and dynamic campaign. It appears that the Labour party has now bullied her into changing her mind. However this is exactly the kind of strongarm Labour tactics which has driven five of their other Councillors away from the divided Labour party."

IDS on the Road to Social Justice

I haven't had a chance to go through Iain Duncan Smith's report in detail yet, but I want to point you towards THIS article by IDS on ConservativeHome in which he explains the background to the report. I don't expect I will agree with all of it but there is no doubt that if we get beyond the ususal political argy-bargy it is a report of immense importance and highlights issues which many politicians would rather shy away from.

ConservativeHome has undergone a facelift this week. I very much like the new clear style and easier navigation. Better get a move on with this site's redesign, I guess!

Brown's New Politics: Let's all Jerk our Knees

And there was me thinking that Gordon Brown wanted a new sort of politics. Labour's reaction to IDS's report on Social Breakdown today proves that nothing has changed. Rather than welcome the report as a contribution to an important debate, or even, heaven forfend, to talk about some of the issues raised in the report, Labour's Andy Burnham responded thus...
This is a con from David Cameron because despite his warm words, he does not
have the money to pay for his proposals. Today's report follows the Forsyth
Commission, which proposed GBP21 billion in tax cuts and now we have billions of
extra commitments. Once again we see a Tory party making incredible commitments based on sums that simply don't add up.

Oh change the record. How is it possible to engage in rational debate when politicians come up with fatuous knee-jerk responses like this? Burnham must know that none of the proposals in either the Forsyth report or the Duncan Smith report have been adopted by David Cameron. He has made no commitments yet, so there are no sums to add up. Not a good start to his cabinet career.

Shapps Denies Astroturfing Allegations

Earlier today LibDem Voice posted THIS, alleging that Tory byelection campaign manager Grant Shapps had used his Youtube account to indulge in a bit of astroturfing. Guido followed it up too. This all seemd a bit odd to me so I went to the horse's mouth and have got a categoric denial that Grant did anything of the sort. It appears that he had a very easily guessable password on his Youtube account (it was 1234 !!!) and someone hacked into it. A CCHQ spokesman said...
We have absolutely no idea how this post appeared, however it does appear
someone has been accessing his account. The short password has now been changed
to something more secure. In past two days he has removed a number of posts from
his own YouTube videos which had appeared without authorisation. We will be
monitoring the account carefully and can't rule out the activities of our
opponents.

I can totally see why Mark Pack and others might have thought the worst and can't blame them for highlighting it. Sometimes the story is not quite as good as one first thinks.

Another Day Another Defection


A sixth Labour councillor in Ealing, Zahida Abbas Noori, has joined the Conservatives this morning.. Click HERE to see what happened...

The two graphs above are fascinating. The first shows how the Betfair odds on a victory for Tony Lit in Ealing Southall have shortened over time and the second one shows how the odds on a LibDem victory have lengthened.

In addition, two LibDem councilllors in Colchester have switched to the Tories, putting the Tories in control of the council for the first time in 20 years. More from the East Anglian Daily Times HERE.

Monday, July 09, 2007

Nadine's Blonde Tractor Moment

Did you know it's Red Tractor Week? Well, the chances are you will soon. A group of politicians has just been in Covent Garden promoting Red Tractor Week (the pics you see on farm assured food in supermarkets). The square was covered in crash barriers as the politicians had to race little Massey Ferguson tractors against each other. If I tell you that among the participants were Lembit Opik and the Cheeky Girls, and Tory MP Nadine Dorries, you will probably guess that there was an "incident".

At the vital moment in the race Nadine discovered that her brakes didn't work. She careered through a crash barrier, knocked it flying and then took out a BBC camera and camerman (who was bruised and winded, but ok). Somehow Nadine still contrived to come second. She said: "It wasn't my fault, the brake. It really didnt work I swear to god." Expect the carnage to appear on Youtube before too long...

Cameron Has NOT Accepted IDS'S Drinks Tax Proposals

Yesterday I didn't write about the ludicrous proposal in Iain Duncan Smith's report to put up taxes on alcohol. I wanted to find out what the status of these proposals were. To all those who have frothed at the mouth you should know that they have NOT been accepted by David Cameron, and I hope they won't be.


Like many of you, I am fed up with politicians whose knee jerk reaction to a problem is instinctively to suggest putting up taxes. There are often far better actions one can take. Adding a few pence to a pint of beer will do absolutely nothing to stop binge drinking, but it will of course provide extra tax revenues for the Treasury to squander.

Iain Duncan Smith's aim is to raise £400 million to build new drug and alcohol treatment centres, a laudable aim in itself, but quite achieveable without putting up taxes. For God's sake, we're Conservatives. We do not believe in putting up taxes. If one is serious about curbing binge drinking we could ban 'happy hours' or 'two for one' offers. At least these would address the problem, even if I might have sever reservations about interfering with a pub's right to run its own affairs.

Having been round a drug treatment centre with IDS in North Norfolk I know how passionate he is on this issue, and rightly so. But surely there are £400 million worth of government funds which can be reallocated without introducing further regressive taxation. To pretend that it will have any effect on binge drinking is patent nonsense given the disposable income of teenagers and twentysomethings noawadays.

IDS's report has made more than 200 suggestions and I hope the sensible ones won't be overshadowed by this one. His report is a fantastic piece of work and he should get a lot of credit for it.

Five Labour Councillors Defect to Ealing Southall Tories

Tom Watson MP, Labour's by election campaign manager in Ealing Southall, has just had the shock of his life. Five Labour councillors in Ealing Southall have just defected to the Conservatives and the Independent by-election candidate, Gulbash Singh, will this morning abandon his own campaign to become Ealing Southall's next MP and instead join Tony Lit's campaign. The Ealing Five, as they are bound to become known, have just released a joint statement...
It has become increasingly obvious as this by-election campaign has progressed, that the Conservative candidate Tony Lit is the best person to represent Ealing Southall as our next MP. He's energetic, dynamic and displays the kind of qualities that would make him ideally suited to represent the people of Ealing Southall. We wanted to provide him with our backing and joining the Conservative Party sends the clearest possible message.

Locally since Conservatives took control of Ealing Council in May 2006 we have noticed that they have been making great strides towards trying to improve the quality of life for all our residents. We've finally reached the stage where it has become blatantly obvious that we would be doing own voters a great disservice if we continue to dogmatically stick with a disorganised and divided Labour Party. Our goal is to see genuine improvements for our residents. We believe that the Conservative Party now provides our community with greater opportunities and is genuinely interested in improving services for all.

At a national level we are extremely impressed by David Cameron's modern Conservatives and, with the changes that he has now made, we feel that the Conservative Party now best represents our views. In a sense we believe the
Conservatives have become our natural home and we are very excited about the opportunity to play a full part in a Party which we believe is destined to form the next government.

The five defectors are Cllr Gurcharan Singh, Cllr Manjit Singh, Cllr Maninder Kaur Keith, Cllr Jarnail Singh Jandu, Cllr Jagdish Gupta. Hilariously, Pickled Politics reckons the defection of Cllr Singh from Labor is a "blow" to the Conservatives. God knows how they will spin the defection of the other four.

George Bush Senior once said that to win an election you had to have the "Big Mo". It is far too early to say the Conservatives will win this by election but few observers would deny that it is they who have had the best start. Tom Watson's campaign is disintegrating by the day.

UPDATE 10:33: The LibDems are a bit behind the times. Ten minutes ago they put up THIS statement on their website. Get with it, guys!

Sunday, July 08, 2007

Labour Bully Boy Tactics in Sedgefield

What on earth is the Labour Party up to in Sedgefield? First they send their attack dogs to disrupt the LibDem campaign launch and then they try to do the same to David Cameron. Tory candidate Graham Robb writes on his blog...
These issues were not of any concern to Labour activists who tried to distrupt
David Cameron's visit. Fairly typically for a Party in trouble Labour tried their
best to stop us raising the issus and proposing alternatives. A silly stunt
involving a 'butler' was aiming to portray David as 'posh' but really he was
here caring about the policies I am proposing. I am the only candidate to have
issued a plan for the town centre, all Labour want to do is shout me down.

Perhaps this is what Gordon Brown means by the "new politics".

LibDem Voice Becomes More Like Pravda Every Day

There was a time when I would read LibDem Voice most days. It contained some sparky pieces which could be both informative and entertaining. And then Rob Fenwick gave it up. Since then it has gradually become little more than a LibDem party mouthpiece. Today it has sunk to depths previously unplumbed. Click HERE to read an article which would like you to think that the local newspaper is coming to the aid of the LibDems. Mark Pack's story reads...

Pardes Weekly is turning out to be the most lively local newspaper during the
Ealing Southall by-election. You might be hard-pressed though to work out their
view of the Labour campaign from the latest edition.

Mark shows one story from the front page of this newspaper (even though it doesn't even say anything about the LibDems), but oddly Mark doesn't show the rest of the front page. I wonder why not. Well, let's see, shall we?



And he specifically wouldn;t want to draw attention to this front page piece, would he?



Stick that on one of your Focus leaflets!

Hoby: A New Era Has Begun, Has It Not?

Courtesy of Hoby. Click to enlarge

LibDem Blogger Praises Ealing Tory Candidate & More...

Susanne Lamido's Suz Blog is a LibDem blog worth reading. It's, er, very pink, but highly entertaining in its up front honesty. I was told some months ago that she had been chucked out of the LibDems but she still bangs the LibDem drum. However, she seems to have caused a bit of a stir today by praising Tony Lit, the Tory candidate in the Ealing Southall by-election. On her blog today, she criticised the Labour candidate and then wrote this...
By comparison the Tory candidate Tony Lit, is swathe, charismatic and oozes confidence. They have certainly scored a blinder by selecting him. I don't know much about him either but from chats with Asian friends, his Sunrise Radio is the only station many of them listen to. Several close Asian LibDems have also made the same point. Who will win the by-election is anybody's guess at the moment. The polls vary depending on which you look at. It is presumed Labour will win given the Brown factor and the respect the community had for the former MP Piara Khabra (deceased). However the Tony Lit factor will eat into both the Labour and LibDem vote and we may see some surprises.

She's also done a blog post on the LibDem candidate in Sedgefield, Greg Stone, HERE. Greg is the brains behind Labour Watch, a site which has curiously been taken down. The LibDem campaign launch was disrupted by Labour thugs who have apparently taken none to kindly to Greg Stone. Indeed, he seems very nervous about being linked to his own website at all. I guess the experience of Jody Dunn and her Hartlepool by election blog is giving him a few sleepless nights. I hate to break it to Greg but someone, somewhere will have a cached version of the site. So precious has Greg become over his blog that he has asked Suz Blog to remove all mention of it. He emailed her to say...
Any chance you could do me a favour and take down your post on me being the
Sedgefield candidate? After the Hartlepool experience of Jody I'm not
particularly keen to draw attention to Labour Watch...... Labour sites are
already linking to your post and I'd rather not give them the ammunition!

Hmmm. Too late.

Blogger's Block

I am suffering from 'blogger's block' today. A nation mourns...

Confessions of a Tory Candidate

Caroline Righton is the Conservative candidate for St Austell & Newquay. She has written a diary for the Mail on Sunday of her experience of getting on the candidates list and then getting selected. Read it HERE.

The Sunday Mirror has a poll showing a Labour lead of 2% (37-35-17) over the Conservatives. Not so much of a Brown bounce as a Brown blip.

Saturday, July 07, 2007

The 2007 Guide to Political Blogging

Readers may recall that last year I published a 32 page pamphlet called IAIN DALE'S GUIDE TO POLITICAL BLOGGING IN THE UK. This year the Guide will be a paperback book of around 150pages in length and it will again be sponsored by APCO Online. It will be published by Harriman House.

As well as the format being different, so will the content. At the back of the book there will be a comprehensive directory of as many UK based political blogs as I can get details of. If you click HERE you will find a list of 720 blogs. If you are a blogger, please check I have got yours listed and the details are correct. If you know of any blogs not listed please leave a comment.

Last year I compiled the Top 100 lists on my own because there was no time to do it any other way. This year I am asking a panel of people to compile various lists. As well as compiling the Top 50 Conservatives, Labour and LibDem blog lists we want to have Top 10s and Tope 20s for various categories. Fell free to suggest any.

There will also be around twenty or thirty full length articles by blog personalities and media observers.

Do you know of any bloggers who might have unqiue perspectives on particular blog related issues, or of people who have had interesting blogging experiences over the last twelve months?If you have ideas for features or articles which could be included in the book please do let me know as deadlines are getting quite tight.

Thirty Minutes With Michael Gove



Earlier this week I recorded a half hour CLASS OF 2005 interview with Michael Gove. In this clip Michael explains why he moved from journalism into politics. To watch the full 30 minute programme click HERE.

Is Hull the Forgotten City?

Earlier on the Sky News paper review we talked about the worsening flood situation in Hull. The discussed provoked one of my readers, Andy, to send me this email, which I thought I would share with you.
Dear Iain,

As a daily reader of your blog and occasional 18 Doughty Street viewer, I was pleased to see you appearing on Sky News this evening. With regards to the discussion held by yourself and Michael Brown, I was also pleased to see my home city of Hull receiving some attention for the recent flooding we’ve had, and you both speaking compassionately about our stricken city.

Large swathes of Hull lie below sea level, and are protected from regular tidal flooding by the tidal barrier that lies on the River Hull where it meets the Humber Estuary. This guards us faithfully and has done all my life, however two weeks ago we saw weather totally unlike anything I’ve ever seen. Hour upon hour of torrential rain battered the city, and the defences just could not cope.

Virtually everyone in one of the dozen largest cities in England is either flooded out, or knows someone who is. Everyone is affected. A friend of mine called in some distress a while ago delivering the quite shattering news that they won’t be able to go home for a year. I can’t conceive of what that must be like. Now, this rather long-winded preface is meant to give a flavour of the situation, worsened by the fact that
many are reportedly unable to actually get insurance because of Hull’s low-lying
status, and that most of East Yorkshire lies on a flood plain.

I quite agree that people are responsible for their own actions. As a Conservative
myself, I am absolutely loathe to see the Government bailing out people who have
chosen not to safeguard themselves. Huge handouts of public money make me
instinctively anxious. But as I survey the wreckage of a permanently damaged city, my resolve wavers, and may dissolve further if it is true that some properties cannot obtain insurance – and yes, I accept that one should acknowledge the risks inherent in buying a house on a flood plain. But the situation is grave and the suffering is real. There’s no easy answer to this, and I find my principles warring with the scenes of ruin. I’m glad it’s a decision I don’t have to make. I’m even more glad I was spared anything more severe than a flooded garden and some damaged footwear.

Once again, thank you for a sympathetic voice on the television.


A truly terrible situation for all those affected. I suspect those who say if this had happened in Kensington & Chelsea much more would have been done, have a point. Wouldn't you have thought that the fact that Hull boasts Alan Johnson and John Prescott as two of its three MPs would make a bit of a difference to the government's responsiveness? Apparently not.

Friday, July 06, 2007

Discovering the Real Cherie

I haven't seen the REAL CHERIE BLAIR yet. That pleasure will come over the weekend. However, Fiona Millar (aka Mrs alastair Campbell), Cherie's one time personal assistant, has had her say in today's Guardian HERE. Hilarious stuff, as it confirms everything most of had ever thought about Cherie. How on earth did Fiona Millar put up with her for so long?

Who is the real Cherie Blair? Did anyone really know at the end of Wednesday night's BBC fly-on-the-wall documentary? Here was a woman who professes to loathe the media but appeared perfectly happy to invade her own privacy by inviting them into her kitchen while she reheats soup and chats to her son...

In the six years I worked for her husband - a small technical fact that came in handy on the day she phoned up and tried to sack me at the end of the turbulent Peter Foster/Carole Caplin affair - I still like to think we had a happy and productive friendship in which I and others tried our best to help her maintain her career, her public duties as prime minister's wife and other sometimes controversial forays into the world of criminal justice, women's rights and foreign affairs. In spite of the hurt the end of our friendship caused at the time, I can understand why she may have felt her life might be simpler without me. However, her famed intelligence clearly deserts her if
she still can't see that the primary job of anyone employed at No 10 is to protect the interests of the prime minister and his office. If his spouse wants to do things that might bring that office into disrepute, the job of those who work for him is to intervene. Sometimes that means giving uncomfortable advice...

Sadly, Cherie Blair, as she now prefers to be known in spite of the months we spent persuading Downing Street officials that she should be allowed to put "Cherie Booth QC" on her headed notepaper - in order that she retain her separate identity - is leaving No 10 with a mixed reputation. She clearly feels the need to set the record straight. Why else would she have taken
part in this programme? (Although, was I alone in wondering if the BBC was paying her? Why else would she do it?) But the fact that she needs to do that is partly because she chose to ignore the advice of people like me, and others, who, in spite of what she now claims, had her best interests at heart. Over time, she may come to see that. In the meantime, her successors can be very
grateful to her for giving them the support she did not initially have. If they spend a few minutes reading the mountains of correspondence they receive from the British public, they will note that the voters have high expectations of them, are tolerant and affectionate, but fall out of love very quickly if their privileged role is abused.

Tory Campaign in Ealing Going Well

THIS post on ConHome demonstrates why the Tories have Labour and the LibDems on the back foot in the Ealing Southall by-election. No wonder Tom Watson, the Labour campaign manager is throwing his toys out of his pram. The truth of the matter is that he'd rather have Tony Lit as his candidate than the man Labour has chosen. And as for the LibDems, well, the kindest thing to say is ... The LibDems Can't Win Here...

Charles Kennedy, Hypocrisy and Consistency

Poor old Charlie Kennedy. He's headline news at the moment for breaking the smoking ban and smoking out of the window of a train to Plymouth. But what's this I hear? Charlie voted for the smoking ban? No, surely not. Yup, HERE's the evidence.

He also told the Daily Star "The way the world is moving, in terms of people's awareness, perception, concern about health, as well as the liberties of those who do not smoke. I think it is inevitable frankly that is the way it is going to go. And it is something I personally would support." (Daily Star, 20 June 2005).

I have very mixed views ont he smoking ban. I would never have voted for it, but I'm quite happy not to have to put up with cigarette smoke in public places. That probably makes me as much of a hypocrite as Charles Kennedy. The lack of consistency in the policy is astonishing. Surely the logical step is to ban smoking completely. I'm not saying I am in favour of that, but if, from a public health viewpoint it is so bad, that is surely what they should be doing.

Of course the other point is that alcohol can be just as damaging, obesity too. But far from restricting the sale of alcohol the government is happy to make it more easily available. Again, I am not saying I would restrict it as I believe people should be responsible for their own actions. But the mixed messages being sent out from the Department of Health are odd to say the least.

One for the Ladies... (I Think)


Last night on 18 Doughty Street I was asked if I had ever grown a beard. I did once, but it was a bit ginger. Anyway while trying to find a photo of that ugly period in my life I happened across this one, which got my two female guests rather excited. They reckoned I must have starred in a gay porn film. I prefered to think of it on a par with that moment in the latest James Bond film when Daniel Thing emerged from the sea. There is no end to my self-delusion, you see.
Anyway, isn't it marvellous that I haven't changed much in the 22 years since this photo was taken? The creams are obviously working well...
UPDATE: What have I started?
UPDATE: OMG, my secret is out. I starred in V...

Telegraph Column: Weathering the Brown Storm


After a fortnight of remorseless battering, Tory MPs at last have a spring in their step. Gordon Brown's lacklustre performance at PMQs on Wednesday proved to them that the new Prime Minister is far from infallible. One Tory MP walked out of the chamber clenching his fist and shouting "Game on"!

On their own, one dodgy performance by Brown and one good performance by David Cameron mean nothing, but perception is everything in politics, and if these performances are repeated in the three remaining PMQs before the summer recess, Brown's honeymoon will be over almost before it has begun.

Brown had an impressive debut week as PM. Until PMQs, he had hit the right note, both in his response to the terror attacks and his reshuffle. It wasn't until his statement on constitutional issues that the wheels started to come off, and all because he reverted to type.

Forget all the consensual, government of all the talents guff: leopards do not change their spots and politicians who try to be something they patently are not get found out. Cameron's strategy of watching with wry amusement as the New Gordon Brown was marketed to the nation was right. But now he has drawn blood, he should go in for the kill.

Just as Brown is considered a control freak, Cameron is seen to be "policy-lite". In fact, it is Cameron's biggest PR failure that he has allowed this perception to fester: there is actually a raft of policies that Cameron himself has announced.

These policies include the setting up of a pensions lifeboat fund, a 3p reduction in business taxes, the abolition of stamp duty on shares, no more closures of special schools, a Bill on NHS independence, abolishing many NHS targets, reducing carbon emissions, the abolition of ID cards, the introduction of border police, a Bill of Rights, scrapping the council tax revaluation, a referendum on the new EU treaty… you get the picture.

Next week, Iain Duncan Smith's social justice commission will publish its report and the following week David Cameron will publish the globalisation commission report while on a trip to Rwanda, while 40 Tory MPs, candidates and officials will work on 20 "social responsibility projects" throughout the country.

The public services, economic competitiveness, security and environment commissions will all report by the middle of September. Hundreds of people have been involved in working on these policy groups and they are producing work of real substance.

Over the summer, the findings of all the commissions will be analysed by Oliver Letwin's team, and the party will have the opportunity to debate them at conference. A website will contain all the policy recommendations and a forum to allow party supporters to debate the findings. In November, final decisions will be made on which policies will form the basis of a full manifesto.

An interesting, but little commented-on, aspect of David Cameron's shadow cabinet reshuffle was the appointment of William Hague and Francis Maude to roles in policy development. Maude's "enforcer" role is an important one, for it is he who will develop a strategy for implementing policy when in government.

Once Cameron has cherry-picked the recommendations, it will be Maude's job to ensure that the shadow cabinet gets to grips with them quickly.

It is clear that Cameron is gearing up for an election. Caroline Spelman's appointment shows that the role of party chairman will become more political and less organisational. This is balanced by the return of two former officials, Stephen Gilbert and Gavin Barwell.

Their re-emergence will be welcomed by party agents and campaigners. They will continue to plan the target-seats campaign with Lord Ashcroft, whose remit has also been widened to focus on building a campaigning organisation.

Normal politics won't resume until after the party conferences. By then, we will have a much better idea of the policy and election battleground.

Thursday, July 05, 2007

Tom Watson Sinks to the Depths (Again)

Am I alone in thinking that Tom Watson's* latest post on the Conservative Candidate in Ealing Southall is, well, borderline racist? It's also complete rubbish. He's no raising a canard about Tony Lit's directorships being registered at different addresses. Big ****ing deal. Mine probably are/were too. Ooooh. Big conspiracy. And maybe I may have registered one in the name of Iain Dale and one in the name of Iain Campbell** Dale. Obviously I am a criminal.

Mr Watson's lawyers may have some extra communication tomorrow I suspect. What a prize arse he is making of himself.

*Tom Watson is the Labour MP for West Bromwich. He is "masterminding" the Labour by-election campaign. As someone has said in the comments... "Does 'Tom Watson' also go by the name 'Thomas Anthony Watson'?Did he live in Kidderminster, Hull and various other places before becoming MP for West Brom?I think we should be told."
**Yes, it's my middle name.

And here's a response which a reader has emailed which hasn't yet appeared on Tom Watson's blog....

Tom,
I think you’re digging yourself a bigger hole here and need to back out fast. The content of your first post was that the Conservative candidate Tony Lit was not registered to vote. Now you seem to be backtracking by using the exact name “Tony Lit” where-as before you were intimating that the candidate was not registered. The different pseudonyms that Tony uses in his different business directorships is a red herring. Many professional people use different names for different purposes. For example, my wife’s name is Gayle Ould but she publishes academic papers under the title Dr Gayle Ritchie. This is because she published before we got married and now after changing her surname she doesn’t want to confuse people. If someone was to challenge her and say, “Dr Gayle Ould” has never published an academic paper”, then you would be incorrect. This is exactly the same situation with Tony Lit. The use of a different name is irrelevant - the candidate Tony Lit is registered to vote (in the same way that the candidate “Tony Blair” at the last election was registered as “Anthony Blair” - different name but same person) and you need to back down gracefully. Just admit you were wrong - we all make mistakes from time to time.

Sikh Federation Slams Labour Party in Ealing

It seems that many people in Ealing are unimpressed by Labour's by-election candidate. The Sikh Federation has tonight issued a press release announcing it is considering putting up an independent Labour candidate. Here are som extracts...

Last night it was confirmed the Labour candidate would be Cllr Virendra Sharma after the Labour Selection Panel, including Keith Vaz MP and Tom Watson MP decided on a remarkably short list, of two men on Tuesday afternoon. It is reported that fellow Labour MPs like Fiona Mactaggart were furious with the outcome and made their views known with the new Party Chair, Harriet Harman.The Labour Party had already announced in March that it would adopt an all women’s short list with the front runner being Sonika Nirwal. However, as this was a by election and a candidate for Ealing Southall had yet to be announced to replace Piara Khabra, when he stepped down, his untimely death provided the Labour Party with an opportunity to open up the selection process.

The Labour Selection Panel reduced the estimated number of applicants for this safe Labour seat from perhaps as many as 100 to eight candidates on Monday evening. Publicly there were two fairly powerful lobbies – one to ensure a woman was selected and the other to get a Sikh into the Commons, preferably a turban wearing Sikh. It is understood two of the eight on the long list were women – Sonika Nirwal and Jasbir Anand. Seven of the eight were Sikh, with three
turban wearing Sikhs, including Cllr Gurcharan Singh who was widely acknowledged as the person with most support within the local Labour Party membership that would ultimately determine who represented them. Most, but not all, on the long list were local candidates. As there were candidates on the long list that were not local some are asking why excellent candidates, like Dr Harkirtan Singh, who has been short listed before in Denton and Reddish, were excluded on this occasion.After interviews on Tuesday the Labour Selection Panel surprisingly only named two on the short list to take part in hustings that evening and who
would be put to the local Labour Party membership. The hustings on Tuesday night were only for local Labour Party members and reports suggest they proved quite tense as there were many who were upset at the short list. The absence of a woman or turban wearing Sikh in the short list were two of the main concerns.

It has been reported that the Selection Panel wanted somebody similar to the Conservative candidate Tony Lit – “an Asian man with a ‘clean cut’ image”. However, it is been unofficially suggested that part of the thinking was that Sonika Nirwal and Gurcharan Singh had some sort of skeletons in the cupboard that the opposition parties might exploit in the by election. Similar
allegations could be made against the candidate selected, but only time will
tell what tactics and information the opposition parties use.
It is interesting that Labour has chosen to keep media coverage of its chosen candidate very quiet.As Labour has failed to allow a woman or turbaned Sikh to be in the short list there is a risk that an independent Labour candidate will now stand. Labour has brought this on itself. It has also not been lost on the Sikh community in Ealing Southall and throughout the UK that young Sikh professionals have been overlooked for the one ageing non-Sikh on the long list
.


I reckon this is going to be the dirtiest by-election campaign in living memory. And if you want proof, I'm about to post something else which should show you the kind of tactics the Labour Party intends to use.

Take the Iain Dale's Diary Reader Survey

Click here to take the Iain Dale's Diary reader survey

I hope you will take a couple of minutes to take part in my reader survey. It's 20 questions long and will take you less than five minutes to complete. Let me be upfront about its purpose.

I have big plans for this blog over the next six months, which involve expanding its scope and maybe even building a brand new site. To do that I need to fund it and attract more advertising. I therefore need to know some demographic information about my readers as well as finding out what you think I should be doing more/less of and what you like/dislike about the blog and the way I run it.

UPDATE: 1300 people have taken the survey so far. There are some fascinating views, which I will report back on in a few days. If you haven't taken the survey yet, please do so now by clicking on the image above.

Kicking the Terrorists Where It Hurts

THIS is the sort of authoritarian action I thoroughly approve of taking against terrorists.
BATTLING taxi driver Alex McIlveen faced down the Glasgow Airport terror suspects ... and his courage cost him his favourite pair of trainers and a £30 parking fine. Dad-of-two Alex punched and kicked the two men after they crashed a Jeep Cherokee loaded with gas canisters into the door of Terminal One. The 45-year-old booted one of the suspects, whose body was covered in flames, as hard as he could between the legs. But the man didn't appear to feel the blow, and a police doctor told Alex later that he'd damaged a tendon in his foot.

After the drama, police confiscated Alex's trainers for forensic tests. And when he went back to the airport to pick up his cab, he was stunned to find that he'd been given a parking ticket. Alex said: "The police took all the clothes I 'd been wearing so I lost my Nike trainers. They're a good pair too.

"I didn't get out of the police station until late on Saturday night and I found the parking ticket on my cab next day. I couldn't believe it." Alex, of Glasgow, was one of several hero Scots who took on the men who targeted the airport on Saturday afternoon. He punched and kicked the passenger from the Jeep, believed to be Iraqi doctor Bilal Abdulla.

More Tory Reshuffle News

These appointments are unconfirmed...

Andrew Murrison to defence.
Mark Harper moved from defence
Nick Hurd to the whips office
Tobias Ellwood to DCMS
Mark Lancaster to Dfid
Andrew Rosindell to Home Affairs
Robert Syms leaves the front bench
Ben Wallace to Scotland as deputy to David Mundell
Robert Goodwill moved from the whips office
Mark Prisk stays at Business & Enterprise

UPDATE
Mike Penning to Health (not whips office, as I previously reported)
Justine Greening to Treasury
Anne Milton to Health
Mark Hoban stays in post
Jeremy Wright to the whips office

Perhaps the juiciest appointment so far is Paul Goodman's move to assist Sayeeda Warsi at community cohesion. Given his robust views on the muslim issue it's safe to say he has been appointed to 'keep an eye' on her. I also understand that Dominic Grieve will no longer cover diversity issues, which move to Community Cohesion. I have just spoken to Dominic Grieve who assures me that there will be a Community Cohesion 'troika' of himself, Sayeeda and Paul.

UPDATE 10.38am A commenter has said that David Ruffley moves to the Home Office team from Work & Pensions, presumably replacing Nick Herbert to cover police reform

UPDATE 11.27am Mark Simmonds to health
UPDATE 12.20pm Bob Neill to replace Jacqui Lait as Shadow Minister for London
UPDATE: 12.27pm Jacqui Lait to take on planning & development
UPDATE 2.34pm ConHome reporting David Burrows to Justice & ADam Afriyie to Skills & Universities
UPDATE 4.11pm James Clappison to Children & Schools

An Hour With Gyles Brandreth



I know Gyles Brandreth is an acquired taste, but I still reckon his book BREAKING THE CODE is the best political book of the last ten years. Last week I did an hour long interview with him on 18 Doughty Street. The above is a short clip, but if you'd like to see the whole hour, click HERE.

This is what Jilted John thought of it...

"18 Doughty Street with Gyles Brandreth - one of the funniest and brilliant hours of TV I have seen in ages. Absolutely brilliant.

Wednesday, July 04, 2007

A Few Titbits from the Tory Reshuffle

A bit of news from the Tory junior ministerial reshuffle...

David Burrowes gets a job
David Ruffley moved from Work & Pensions
Stewart Jackson & Richard Benyon appointed to the whips office
Maria Miller to shadow childcare under Michael Gove
Geoffrey Clifton Brown moves fromn Foreign Office

OK, OK, I know it's not a lot. I am sure there will be much more later this morning. Stay tuned!

Some Ministers Are More Equal Than Others

Has anyone noticed the number of government ministers who are unpaid - by which I mean they do not receive anything beyond their normal MPs' salaries. There is a strict limit on the number of ministers who can be paid salaries. Here is a list of the ones who have to make do on £59,000...

Secretary of State for N Ireland - Shaun Woodward
Lord in Waiting - Lord Truscott
Minister of State - Lord Drayson
Parliamentary Under Secretary of State - Shahid Malik MP
Parliamentary Secretary - Helen Goodman MP
Parliamentary Under Secretary of State - Lord McKenzie of Luton
Parliamentary Under Secretary of State - Iain Wright MP
Assistant Government Whip - Sadiq Khan MP
Assistant Government Whip - Mark Tami MP

So Britain's first two Muslim ministers don't get paid the same as 95% of their colleagues.

EXCLUSIVE: Labour Breach Electoral Law in Ealing Southall

Tom Watson, Labour blogger and MP, is running the Ealing Southall By-Election campaign for the Labour Party. Later on this evening, he'll be forced to make a very humiliating apology for this blog entry. He wrote...
There is no Tony Lit [the Conservative candidate] registered to vote in Chiswick. I know he only joined the Conservatives last week but running a candidate who isn’t registered to vote strikes me as just peculiar.

Joan Ryan MP, the ex Home Office minister and now vice chair of the Labour Party wrote to George Osborne earlier today alleging the same thing - that the Conservative Candidate is not on any electoral register. In her letter, she said...

How can Tony Lit credibly ask anyone in Ealing Southall to vote for him when
he has not bothered to register to vote himself? Can you please tell me when
Tony Lit intends to register to vote? When local residents in Ealing Southall
realise that the Tony who wants their vote does not have a vote of his own they
too will soon be asking - Who is Tony Lit? I would welcome a speedy response to
my questions. As this is a matter of major public interesy, I am releasing this
letter to the media.

Sadly for Ms Ryan and Tom Watson they haven't done their homework. In fact Tony Lit is on the register under his full family name (Labour recently changed the rules so that you can stand under your common name). He has voted in every election since he was 18. Tory by-election supremo Grant Shapps has now written a stinging resposte to Joan Ryan (who was axed from her Home Office job last week) pointing out that it is in fact illegal to publish false statements about candidates under electoral law.

Dear Joan,
I'm writing in response to your letter to George Osborne with reference to our candidate in the Ealing Southall by-election. In your letter you claim that Mr Lit is not on the electoral register.You are wrong. Tony's full name is Surinderpal Singh Lit. He has voted in every single general election since he was 18 years of age. As you will be aware, it is an illegal practice under electoral law to publish a false statement regarding a candidate, and now that you've been made aware of your error, please confirm that you will now issue a public apology for mistakenly inferring that our candidate is not on the electoral register. I will of course be releasing this letter to the media.

Grant Shapps MP

So it looks as if Labour has committed a bit of a clanger here. Let's see how long it takes Tom Watson to delete his blog entry or apologise. If I were Grant Shapps and I didn't get an apology, I might well be speaking to M'Learned Friend in the morning.

It's All Very Taxing...

Her Majesty's Revenue & Customs says that "tax does not have to be taxing" but an informant tells me that since November 2006 around 1,600 pages have been added to the UK tax code. This means that taxpayers now have just short of 10,000 pages of legislation to consider and an increasingly oppressive system of fines and penalties for those who get it wrong (unless you happen to be an MP or the husband of a cabinet minister when special rules appear to apply.)With these additional pages, the UK now has the longest tax code. India is second with around 9,000 and the Federal US third with 5,100 pages. If you feel that this is all too much and want to cope with something smaller then try Germany with 1,700 or Sweden with 700. Best of all Turkey only has 350 pages or 3.5% of the UK's.

Keith Vaz Selects Labour's By Election Candidate!

The Pickled Politics blog has just reported that the disgraced Labour MP Keith Vaz is playing a key role in the selection of Labour's candidate in the Ealing Southall by-election, and is even on the selection panel. Sunny Hundal writes...
It is now almost a given that Cllr Virendra Sharma will be the Labour party candidate running for the Ealing Southall seat. This is a huge shame because, as one party member told me earlier this morning, they have traded one old and out-of-touch fogey for another. My view is that Sharma will win not because he avoided the factionalism or most likely to get the party votes, but because he managed to woo all the cronies that previously backed Piara Khabra. And guess what, Keith bloody Vaz was on the selection panel. The Labour party has stubbornly stayed away despite knowing all the dirty politics and factionalism at local level, and now they have this mess. They lost the opportunity to give Sonika Nirwal the chance to become the first
Asian woman MP in history and cement its reputation as the natural home for ethnic minorities. It has instead become, in Southall, the natural home for cronyism and dirty politics. But the best thing that could happen for the area and the local Labour
party is that they get routed in this by-election and come back in the general election when boundary changes make it easier for them to reclaim the seat, with the factionalism and old 80 yr old councillors who can barely speak English flushed out. I’ve met Cllr Sharma, he’s not that bad but there are plenty others who are. Either way, a huge missed opportunity for Labour. Respect have also announced their candidate - Salvinder Dhillon, another Sikh man. He will no doubt try and mop up the anti-war vote. The only one who has brand recognition is Tony Lit.

Boris Teases for London

Boris Johnson has just released a statement...
Being Mayor of London would be a fantastic job and anyone who loves London would want to consider the possibility very carefully. I want to stress that this idea did not come from David Cameron or from anyone in his office but I have, of course, been very struck by the number of people who have been urging me to run. In my case, there are huge obstacles – above all my commitment and responsibility to my constituency. It is hard to see how those difficulties could be overcome - but I am ruling nothing out.

So that's a yes, then.

Labour MP Scents West Ham Votes

Mike Gapes, Labour MP for Ilford has put down this Early Day Motion...
That this House welcomes the decision of the Premier League arbitration panel to reject the challenge by Sheffield United and Fulham to the decision to fine West Ham United rather than deduct points; notes their view that this decision was not irrational or perverse; congratulates the players of West Ham United on their magnificent great escape by winning seven of their last nine matches to end the season with 41 points; notes that Sheffield United were relegated because they lost at home to Wigan in their last match and as a result only had 38 points; welcomes the fact that matters of survival and relegation were decided on the field of play and not in the law courts; and wishes West Ham United a successful Premiership season and Sheffield United a successful Championship season in 2007-08.

Naturally, as you would expect, I wholeheartedly agree with his sentiments, but do we really need, as taxpayers to spend £300 on the printing of this rubbish in the Order Paper? Should I ever become an MP, would someone please shoot me if I resort to this sort of thing?

Note: As you can imagine, it was all I could do yesterday to avoid writing about West Ham. Thanks to Mike Gapes for giving me the excuse today!

Brown Trounces Ming at PMQs

The story of PMQs was to have been the clash of the titans, Gordon Brown and David Cameron. However, it turned out to be rather different and the headline was, yet again, a trouncing for Ming.

I certainly felt that David Cameron got the better of Gordon Brown, who looked quite nervous and spoke rather hesitantly. Cameron, by contrast, appeared confident and asked some good questions. Brown answered them competently. The whole exchange felt like initial skirmishings before the main contest.

But Ming Campbell's performance was lamentable and Gordon Brown lost no time in sticking the knife in, saying his "door is always open to the Right Honourable Gentleman". This provoked guffaws from everyone apart from the LibDem benches, who looked as though they were about to throw up. Brown gave Ming the opportunity for a funny follow-up, but the old barrister in him couldn't summon up the killer line and muttered that his door was "more like a trap door". He then asked a weak follow-up question containing three sub questions about nuclear power and council tax.

Oh dear.

John Reid's intervention was interesting in that he made Brown look a fool. Brown had promised David Cameron to look at whether an Islamic extremist group could be banned. Reid intervened to say that he had reviewed the evidence while he was Home Secretary and there wasn't enough evidence for a ban. I actually don't think Reid was trying to cause mischief, but that it the effect of what he said.

So maybe Brown's honeymoon has had a little interruption. Nick Robinson reckons Tory MPs have a spring in their step.

UPDATE: It seems most others found Ming's trap door line much funnier and more impressive than I did. Just shows, you can't win 'em all! Perhaps I shouldn't have been writing a blog post and watching PMQs at the same time. I am obviously emulating President Ford who was memorably accused of not being able to fart and chew gum at the same time. Can;t remember who by though...

UPDATE: Thanks to David Boothroyd for agreeing with me about Ming. Seems we are in a minority of two!

Boris to Run Against Ken Livingstone?

Nick Robinson has just reported that David Cameron is trying to persuade Boris Johnson to run for London Mayor. It would be a massive leap for Boris to take and involve a number of risks, not least to his own Henley seat. Boris is undoubtedly the most popular Conservative in the country and he would surely be tempted to run. The rest of us would relish the spectacle of a Boris v Ken fight.

I felt it would be worth taking the risk of promoting him to the Shadow Cabinet, but perhaps we now know the reason why it didn't happen. At least we can, unlike in the case of Greg Dyke, be sure that Boris is a Conservative!

So what does everyone think? Boris for Mayor?!

graphic from Theo Spark

Is the Taxpayer Funding The Speaker's Legal Bills?

Private Eye reports this week that the Speaker of the House of Commons, Michael Martin, is using the media lawyers Peter Carter Ruck to act as media spokesmen for him. I do hope that their fees are being paid by Michael Martin himself. After all, the Speaker's Department already pays Luther Pendragon PR to do their public relations. Perhaps someone should launch an FOI request. It's just this sort of information which Michael Martin wants to keep quiet, hence his covert support for the David Maclean Bill.

UPDATE: The Taxpayers' Alliance has taken up my suggestion and sent an FOI request to the Speaker's office...

FREEDOM OF INFORMATION REQUEST FOR DETAILS OF PAYMENTS MADE TO
PETER CARTER RUCK BY OR WITH THE AUTHORISATION OF SIR MICHAEL MARTIN, SPEAKER OF
THE HOUSE OF COMMONS

Dear Mr Castle,

I am writing to
request information under the Freedom of Information Act 2000. In order to assist you with this request, I am outlining my query as specifically as possible. I would like to know who pays for the media services provided by Peter Carter Ruck in relation to the Speaker of the House of Commons, Michael Martin

*If these costs are not paid wholly by Sir Michael Martin, I would like to know where the funding for these services comes from?

*If it is from a public source I would like to know the name of that source and the amount paid to them for services in the last three years (or since they first began working for the Speaker).

Regards,
Blair Gibbs


Alan Johnston is Released in Gaza

The BBC is reporting that journalist Alan Johnston has been released after four months in captivity in Gaza. I've never met Mr Johnston but my heart leapt at the news. Sometimes things turn out right in the end.

Tuesday, July 03, 2007

Labour Selection Turmoil in Ealing

News from the Ealing by election, where Cllr Sonika Nirwal, Leader of Labour's opposition group of Ealing Council has been ditched in favour of an all-male shortlist. A National Executive Committee (NEC) supervised meeting picked a shortlist of two men, veteran Ealing councillor Virendra Sharma and Oxford-educated barrister Jo Sidhu. Cllr Sharma, who has long fancied the seat, is hotly-tipped to win the internal selection tomorrow. There is speculation that another veteran Ealing councillor, Gurcharan Singh, may run as an independent after he failed to make the Southall shortlist.

Of course, the bigger story from Ealing Southall is that if the selection had prooceeded in the normal way, it would have been an All-Women Shortlist. Instead, it is an all-male shortlist. And Harriet Harman is the party chairman responsible for all this shambles. So much for her pledges on increasing the number of women in parliament. In her first act as party chair she's carved out all the women!

UPDATE 9.56am: According to THIS wikipedia entry edited last night, Virendra Sharma has already been selected!

A Great Example of Disjointed Government

One of the issues addressed by Gordon Brown today was a greater Parliamentary role in public appointments. Specifically, he said that ‘it is right that this House of Commons vote on the appointment of the Chair of the new Independent Statistics Board’.

As it happens, Tory MP David Gauke proposed something very similar during the Public Bill Committee proceedings of the Statistics and Registration Service Bill but it was voted down by the Government earlier. However, just yesterday, he raised the possibility of greater Parliamentary involvement in the appointment of the members of the Statistics Board. The answer he received from Angela Eagle, the Exchequer Secretary, was:
‘On the third issue, the hon. Member for South-West Hertfordshire asked about board appointments and whether there might be a role for Parliament. Clearly, Parliament will not have an added role and not in respect of the initial board
appointments. As the hon. Gentleman knows, the national statistician is a Crown
appointment and board appointments will be made by appropriate Ministers—ahead, I believe, of the setting up and going live of the new board in April 2008. A
proper appointments process has to be in place for that.’
(See column 709 of Official Report for 2 July).
Does this suggest a lack of communication within the Government?

Alex Salmond's Broken Promise

Mr Eugenides has a good story tonight HERE. He accuses Alex Salmond of breaking a pretty important election pledge that he would refuse his Westminster salary if he was elected to the Scottish Parliament. But what's this? A very revealing PQ on 29 June from the lovely LibDem MP, Jo Swinson...

Jo Swinson: To ask the Leader of the House which hon. Members elected at the
2005 election are not drawing their salaries as hon. Members. [146477]
Ms Harman: All current Members elected at the 2005 election are at present drawing their salary except for the five Sinn Fein MPs, none of whom have taken the Oath.

How very odd...

Ming Campbell Caption Competition


"Honestly Officer, I haven't been paying people in Ealing & Southall to put up posters."
(As covered in yesterday's Standard)

Kerron Cross on Image...LOL

Kerron Cross is the 18 Doughty Street guest blogger this week. He's written a very amusing post today on image, to tie in with the return of THE THICK OF IT to our screens tonight. Read it HERE.

LibDem Reshuffle Underway

Ming Campbell has started to reshuffle his front bench, I gather. They're saying that there will be few changes. If Ming is being vicious expect Chris Huhne to be moved to a less prominent role.

UPDATE: Ming's new team has been announced. Click into the comments as someone has kindly posted them there. Demotion for Sarah Teather. Norman Baker returns. David Laws takes on schools. Er, that's about it.

Nick Boles Pulls Out of Mayoral Race

I'm very sad to have to report that Nick Boles has pulled out of the London mayoral race due to having to undergo treatment for cancer. It's been caught early so he stands an excellent chance of making a full recovery, but obviously his health takes precedence over his political and professional life. I've just spoken to Nick and he is in good spirits but he faces a tough few months. I hope all of you will join me in wishing Nick all the best in his fight against this dreadful disease.