Showing posts with label Des Browne. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Des Browne. Show all posts

Monday, April 16, 2007

Swiss Toni aka Des Browne Survives - For Now

"You know Paul, defending yourself at the Despatch Box is very much like making love to a beautiful woman. You grip it tightly with both hands, thrust youself forward and then unload yourself, before meekly apologising at the quality of the delivery..."

Hapless. That's the only word to describe Des Browne, who I gather is known as 'Swiss Toni' in the armed forces. I have rarely seen a weaker dispatch box performance from a Cabinet Minister than the one the Secretary of State has just given. When you make a statement as a Minister you are supposed to reply to points made by the Opposition Spokesman. Des Browne answered hardly any of the points made by Liam Fox, most importantly the accusation that he had ignored Queen's Regulations which clearly outline that the decision on whether the servicemen and women should have been able to sell their stories to the press was HIS decision and not the Navy's.


Sky News has just pointed out several inconsistencies in Browne's statement and I do not believe he is off the hook. Up to now, I have taken the view that this is an issue which is not serious enough to warrant a resignation. However, all the people I know in the Armed Forces tell me that Browne's reputation is shot to pieces and they all want him gone. In the end, that's what will do for him if anything does.

Thursday, April 12, 2007

An Example of Good Opposition

I think the Conservatives have handled the issue of the navy 15 and selling their stories quite superbly. Liam Fox, William Hague and David Cameron have been careful not to go over the top and instead have asked all the right questions without appearing to be too opportunistic, which is a danger oppositions all too often succumb to. Take this quote from David Cameron this morning...
I think Downing Street is in complete confusion and I think the Prime
Minister has got to make absolutely clear when he knew about this whole issue.
But, to me, what matters for the Defence Secretary is he has to pass two tests.
First, he has to show he still has the confidence of members of our Armed
Services, who are working so hard for our country. And secondly he has to give a
full account of himself to the House of Commons on Monday. And I think it is
very important he does that.

This is what proper Opposition is all about - hold the government to account, show you're on the side of the people affected, and then gently stick the knife in without anyone realising you've done it.

I'm not sure I would like to be Des Browne on Monday. But just as important as Browne's performance will be that of Liam Fox. He must not go over the top in his language, yet he needs to make clear the seriousness of Browne's crass decision. It should be an interesting afternoon.