Saturday, November 07, 2009

Your Ideal Political Dinner Party

I was talking to someone the other day about the demise of the dinner party. And it set me thinking. If I held a dinner party for twelve people in politics who I know, who would I invite to guarantee the sparkiest conversation? Anyway, this is the list I came up with...

Christine Hamilton
Yasmin Alibhai-Brown
Gyles Brandreth
Professor Peter Hennessy
Jeremy Paxman
Michael Cockerell
Ann Widdecombe
Emily Maitlis
Shirley Williams
Tony Benn
Professor Mary Beard


The thing is, would I get a word in edgeways? Probably not, but for once in my life I think I would enjoy just listening!

So if you were doing the inviting, who would you choose?

49 comments:

  1. Um, I suspect I would just want to turn the music up.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Good set but Emily Maitlis must be doubtful and as for Yasmin (I can't be arsed to check how her name is spelt) is a squawk to far.

    How about Mary Anne Big Head for the other baddy and Betty Boothroyd (although her biog was an awful lot of what Betty did next..)

    ReplyDelete
  3. are you sure Emily Maitlis is being invited for a "sparky political conversation"

    ReplyDelete
  4. None of the above except maybe Gyles Brandreth and Ann Widdicombe.
    Frederick Forsyth, Daniel Hannan, and of course Boris!

    ReplyDelete
  5. Yasmin Alibhai-Brown? Halloween was last week so you might want to plan for sometime around the next Crufts.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Tony Benn, I would not break bread with that man.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Osama bin laden , and all the current cabinet , Dress code ...armed !

    ReplyDelete
  8. I think it would be unfair to invite Paxo to such a gathering.

    Are you sure he is up to having a conversation? My impression is that his default mode is one way, like as in a preacher.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Says everything you need to know about you Mr Dale.

    What a load of pompous, boring self opinionated under achieving windbags.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Roger Scruton
    The lovely Trixy

    The even lovelier Er Indoors
    Boris Johnson

    Gillian Tett
    Matthew Parris

    Tamzin Lightwater
    Fraser Nelson

    Rachel Sylvester
    Rod Liddle

    Shami Chakrabarti (token house-trained leftie)
    Yer humble servant

    No. Not a single MP.

    ReplyDelete
  11. George Osborne
    Matthew Parris
    Melanie Phillips
    Michael Gove
    Clarissa Dickson Wright
    James Purnell
    Hazel Blears
    Rory Stewart
    Laura Kuensberg
    Sayeeda Warsi
    Ayan Hirsi Ali
    and Iain Dale of course

    ReplyDelete
  12. Andrew Neil
    Alister Campbell
    Gerry Adams
    Ian Paisley
    Michael Portillo
    Diane Abbott.
    Iain Dale (as long as he does not secretly tweet under the table)
    Kenneth Clarke
    Nigel Lawson.

    ReplyDelete
  13. (Assuming that among the living, I could resurrect dead people, not that I have Godlike powers...)

    Winston Churchill
    Teddy Roosevelt
    Chinggis Khan
    Margaret Thatcher
    Charles de Gaulle
    Alexander the Great
    Leon Trotsky
    Ernest Shackleton
    L Ron Hubbard
    Martin Luther King
    Jesus Christ
    ...and me, to listen in.

    ReplyDelete
  14. I'd invite Kerry McCarthy. Mainly so I could throw a meat pie at her.

    ReplyDelete
  15. Not another list. Please place me on your list (you must have one) of people who have stopped reading your blog and taken you off their favourites list.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Seebag, if only I had known it was that simple. Bye then.

    ReplyDelete
  17. Wasn't there an old Tory joke about the reverse concept, ie the dinner party from hell, in which the hostess greets each guest with the words: "Do come in, Sir Geoffrey's on sparkling form tonight."

    ReplyDelete
  18. Have you checked your invitees to establish whether they are vegetarian, vegan, gluten intolerant, allergic to certain foods, follow religious diets, or simply don't like pot noodle? I find it easier to ask guests to bring sandwiches.

    ReplyDelete
  19. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  20. How about having?

    Gordon Brown
    John Wilkes Booth
    Jose Manuel Barosso
    Ramon Mercador (with Ice Axe of Course)
    Harriet Harman
    Lee Harvey Oswald
    David Cameron
    John Bellingham
    Anthony Charles Lyndon Blair
    Marcus Junius Brutus

    ReplyDelete
  21. Why anyone would sit and listen voluntarily to Alibaba Brown talking her usual drivel is quite beyond me.

    ReplyDelete
  22. My choice:

    Anita Anand
    Peter Oborne
    Lady Helena Kennedy
    Charles Kennedy
    Naomi Klein
    Timothy Garton Ash
    Shirley Williams
    Bianca Jagger
    Rhod Sharpe
    Tim Franks
    Michele Obama

    ReplyDelete
  23. Gordon Brown
    Alister Darling
    Jack Straw
    Harriet Harman
    Ed Balls
    Jacqui Smith
    Peter Mandleson
    Peter Hain
    David Blunkett
    Beatrix Campbell
    Keith Vaz
    Tony McNulty
    Vernon Coaker

    Venue:The Fat Duck, Bray, Berkshire, as featured in:

    http://www.guardian.co.uk/uk/2009/sep/10/fat-duck-food-poisoning-sewage

    Unfortunately, the table available is not big enough to invite the rest of the deserving participants

    ReplyDelete
  24. Anyone who drinks copious red wine, loves real ale and likes a few malt whiskies. Oh and Dawn Primarolo to try and tell us all how bad we are for drinking more than 21/14 units in one night. Then she gets pissed having half a shandy!

    As an ex-navy man. Definitely any MP who is ex-service and let the wine flow to know what they really think about government defence policy. There is an old service saying...what goes on in the mess, stays in the mess (as long as it is quite legal of course!).

    Anyone serve in Germany been to a mess dinner and ended up having a fruhstuck???

    ReplyDelete
  25. David Cameron
    Liam Fox
    Vladimir Putin
    Mikhail Saakashvili


    Ho hum.

    ReplyDelete
  26. David Trimble
    Owen Paterson
    Douglas Carswell
    John Heyes
    Roger Helmer
    oh yes and of course Iain Dale himself - the only one I haven't had dinner with previously.

    And with my selection Iain you would be able to talk as well as listen. The bullshit factor would be absent. You might find yourself learning a few things.

    If there are to be females,

    Theresa May
    Kate Moss
    Cheryl Cole
    Edna Everidge

    ReplyDelete
  27. John Redwood ? Douglas Carswell ? William Hague ? and to be honest, I would like to shoot the breeze with George Osborne-I really want to know his angle on the financial mess we're in

    ReplyDelete
  28. Michael Burleigh
    Niall Ferguson
    Michael Gove

    to discuss islamism and fanatism generally

    Clarissa Dickson-Wright
    Anne Widdecombe
    Lord Terry Burns

    to discuss hunting

    Ronnie Corbett
    Alan Carr
    Shazia Mirza

    to tell funny stories

    and Emily Maitliss just to sit next to me!

    ReplyDelete
  29. Stephen Fry
    Prince Phillip
    Emily Maitlis
    Shami Chakrabarti
    Diane Abbott.
    Russell Brand
    Alan Carr
    Kirsty Young
    Ian Hislop

    And IAIN DALE, who will report on the guest list and the conversations and fall outs that I am sure will happen. Or have I got news for you!

    ReplyDelete
  30. DoesItMatter: 8:29
    You forgot Klaus von Stauffenberg!

    ReplyDelete
  31. Like you:

    Tony Benn
    Christine Hamilton

    And:

    David Cameron
    Gillian Anderson
    Matthew D'Ancona
    Paul O' Grady
    Paul McCartney
    Stephen Hawking
    Richard Normington
    David Bellamy
    (And of course yourself)

    ReplyDelete
  32. If it's "not getting a word in edgeways" you're after why not just stick at Yasmin Alibhai-Brown. You could just have her on a loop.

    ReplyDelete
  33. From Tony Benn's diaries I got the distinct impression that Shirley Williams is almost brain-dead, though this may just be a bitter Labour left vs Labour right thing. Might be amusing to put them next to each other so they can have a nice chat about nuclear power and oooh, I don't know, party loyalty?!

    ReplyDelete
  34. That list is just weird. Maybe it's just designed to provoke comment.

    Oh, I fell for it. Durr.

    ReplyDelete
  35. I am reminded of the comment made by Reggie Perrin in the original, when told to cancel his dinner party with Mr & Mrs CJ because of his wife's illness, but deciding instead to invite David Harris-Jones, Davina Letts-Wilkinson and his Uncle Percy Spillinger: "if that doesn't put the cat amongst the pigeons, I don't know what will". Applying those principles: -

    Simon Heffer
    Jo Brand
    Danny Finkelstein
    Ruth Lea
    Richard Littlejohn
    Polly Toynbee
    Matthew Parris
    Edwina Currie
    Christopher Booker
    Shirley Williams
    Al Gore
    Susan Greenfield

    Let those feathers fly!

    ReplyDelete
  36. Michael Howard
    Alistair Campbell
    George Osborne
    Peter Mandelson
    Peter Hitchens
    Christopher Hitchens
    Prof. David Nutt
    Mary Whitehouse

    Yes, I realise I'd probably have to use paper/plastic tableware...

    ReplyDelete
  37. Jesus... Yasmin Alibhai-Brown???

    If you wanted a racist at the table why not just go straight to the source and invite Nick Griffin?

    ReplyDelete
  38. I think I would go for:

    Harold Wilson
    Margaret Thatcher
    David Starkey
    Tony Benn
    Claire Short
    Douglas Murray
    Lance Price
    Edwina Currie
    Kenneth Clarke
    David Owen
    Germaine Greer
    Professor Peter Hennessy

    Please let it happen!

    ReplyDelete
  39. I would invite Harry Hill, yourself and He Who Shalt Not Be Named. You know, the crap blogger who is always slagging you off under his "Mental" pseudonym. Or some name along those lines. The one Dizzy refers to as Lassie - you know who I'm talking about.

    There's only one way to sort this out... FIGHT!

    ReplyDelete
  40. I would wish to learn what my guests do not like so I can arrange the menu accordingly.

    Initially I would just like an intimate one to one dinner party and my first guest would have to be Gordon Brown.

    Having discovered his least favourite dish,I would serve it with a flourish. With just a little extra helping of garlic!

    He will discover plenty of wine, (bought from Lidl or Aldi), decanted into the more expensive looking bottles, from the evening before! Plenty of Brandy and Whisky -just to get his tongue loose!

    Of course the room will have plenty of microphones and hidden camera's to catch his every word- so I can reveal to the world those secrets he may well tell me.

    My next one to one guest would have to be Blair, followed by David Cameron during which Cameron will finally tell me what drugs he took and what political party he feels more attachment to, as it certainly cannot be the Tory party!

    ReplyDelete
  41. If you're going to invite Shirly Williams, then drop YAB and Benn replace with Christopher Hitchens and Salman Rushdie.

    ReplyDelete
  42. Nigel Farage, George Galloway, Richard Branson

    If English speaking foreigners were to be allowed in:
    Le Kuan Yew
    Professor Laffer
    Sarah Palin
    Newt Gingrich
    Professor Fred Singer

    ReplyDelete
  43. Robert Murphy - American Austrian economist who thinks the stimuli packages and bank bailouts have gone way too far.

    Paul Krugman - an American economist in the NY Times who thinks the stimuli and bailout packages haven't gone far enough.

    Peter Schiff - to provide morale and ideoligical support to Murphy.

    Nigel Lawson.

    Melanie Phillips

    David Starkey

    Roger Scruton

    Gordon Brown - just to give him the chance to learn sthg.

    ReplyDelete
  44. As I am unable to get my mind out of the cess pit my first thought was there is only one woman on the list that I would want to stay for afters.

    ReplyDelete
  45. Far too many of those have seriously impaired moral compasses (Benn, Yasmin, Hamilton, Williams), and such a confused, inconsistent and muddled world view as to make you wonder which way the world turns round. What you need to balance the nutters is a serious historian, like Sir Martin Gilbert.

    For a real bunfight, why not ask Chomsky, Pilger and Red Ken?

    ReplyDelete
  46. I'd pay good money not to attend!

    ReplyDelete
  47. Lady Thatcher - I've got questions about Poll Tax and Nurses Pay

    Churchill - For advice on how to deral with Nazis

    Nick Griffin - So Churchill can slap him and make him apolgise for the slur on his name

    Kenneth Williams - The man was a God, genius and very good at a dinner party

    David Cameron - I need some champagne autographed

    Christopher Biggins - Star quality

    Michael Caine - To discuss social inequality

    Boris Johnson - Another damn fine fellow

    Bonnie Greer - Impressed by her on QT

    My mum and dad - Add some normal, everyday edge to the chat

    Monty - I want some insights into figthing the Desert Fox

    The Iraqi Information Minister - Remember him????

    Sound fun?

    ReplyDelete
  48. The only way I would want to go for a dinner with Yasmin A-B present is if she was on the menu - though I suspect she would be a bit gristley.

    ReplyDelete